Comment 1 (Grobius) Secret society in London; locked-room murder -- lots of luck to make this work. Ben Soar is a fine character, as are several of the others; but on the whole, the mystery is not very good, depending as it does on an Olympic-style feat and the stupidity of the victim. This is a red herring, fairly typical of Carr/Dickson: secret societies, witch cults, supernatural events, malignant ghosts, etc. While usually shot down as really applicable to the solution, these touches add atmosphere and mystery, but not very much in this case, since no attempt is made to make it a serious part of the story.
-- PS: This is one of a series of Carter Dicksons issued by IPL publishers with some very fine Nicky Zann cover drawings. Zebra had some good ones depicting Fell, Gaunt, and Bencolin, but nothing near these evocative and amusing pictures that IPL did.
|
Comment 2 (The_Thin_Man) Also known as "THE TEN TEACUPS". After "The Waxworks Murders", this is Carr's best book. The characters are superb. It's worth buying for the duel between H.M. and the murderer's accomplice alone, which is hugely atmospheric and includes the problem of a disappearing man leaving behind only a blood trail, the revelation of a murderer's identity, the appearance of ANOTHER corpse, a legendary duel-of-wits between H.M. and his quarry, and the final shock appearance of an as-yet-unsuspected murderer. For sheer volume of criminally-inclined people, this book beats "The Four False Weapons", and yet it has all of that novel's strengths and none of its flaws. This really is one of the best, and Carr fans should snap it up. |