| The Skeleton in the Clock | [] | (1948) |
| Author: Dickson | Detective: Merrivale | Type: CD |
Publisher's Blurb 1958 Pan:
FEAR
clutched the five of them as they groped their way through the dank, enveloping darkness of the deserted prison—
a fear intensified by the spirits of those long dead.
Curiosity started it all, at 3 am in Ruth Callice’s flat.
… It ended with MURDER!
|
Comment 1 (Grobius) Country-house murder way in the past; improbable solution; do you remember the TV series "Banacek" with all its flashbacks? There are a couple of good set pieces: one in an abandoned prision condemned cell (reminiscent of Hag's Nook) and a climactic scene in a mirror maze; the rest is middling but not actually bad. Do people remember events from 20 years ago in such detail? Also can one hide behind a six-inch-high parapet? The killer, unusually for this author, is actually psychopathic.
|
Comment 2 (hacklehorn) The last readable H.M.--H.M. does function, both as detective and as comic relief (the business with the skeleton is genuinely funny--pure Edmund Crispin, as is his duel with Lady Brayle). Murder was committed twenty years before the action, and murder is sparked off in the present by anonymous letters. The prison scenes show Carr's unrivalled skill in creating atmosphere--but is let down by some pig-headnedness among the male characters. The subject matter (murdered children) is particularly nasty, and nasty in a very different way from THE PLAGUE COURT MURDERS or THE BURNING COURT--this is genuine headline stuff, and not the Mayhem Parva of which Carr and others were accused. The murderer's identity is a genuine surprise, although insanity is a weak motive (or is it?--could this be one of Carr's most realistic tales?). |
Comment 3 (The_Thin_Man) One of Carr's most convincingly nasty murderers, and also one of his most surprising despite a wealth of clues - Carr plays scrupulously fair in this one. Some of the characters could do with more characterisation - Cecily in particular - but this is one of Carr's best. The prison scenes are unforgettable. |
Comment 4 () |
| URL: | URL: | Rating: 7 |